In cases of sexual or interpersonal violence, educators often guide youth toward the criminal legal system as a primary response. However, reporting can be a difficult and disheartening experience, often yielding disappointing results. Additionally, how the law defines a "crime" may differ significantly from how a victim perceives their own experience. If we are encouraging minors to report or are mandated to ourselves, we should understand what the process entails and take steps to prepare young people and help manage expectations.